A List of Independent Cincinnati Ice Cream Shops

Discover Cincinnati’s sweetest hidden gems! This curated list highlights locally owned ice cream shops serving up unique flavors, handcrafted treats, and hometown charm. Taste the best of the Queen City—one scoop at a time.

Legen-Dairy Whip Bethel Ohio
Legen-Dairy Whip Bethel Ohio sign

Legen-Dairy Whip

Bethel's beloved spot for creative, generous soft-serve, sundaes, and sweet treats. A true local gem!

Bethel

Legen-Dairy Whip of Bethel is a charming and beloved dairy bar in Bethel, Ohio, known for its extensive selection of creative soft-serve sundaes, milkshakes, and other delightful treats. Beyond classic flavors, they offer unique options like Cry Baby Blue and various custom concoctions. The "legen-dairy" experience is enhanced by generous portion sizes, a welcoming atmosphere often featuring whimsical Bigfoot decorations, and the occasional presence of local food trucks. It's a community favorite for families and anyone seeking a memorable sweet escape.

⭐ Rating: 4.8/5, 362 reviews

Sunday 2–9 PM ? Monday Closed ? Tuesday 2–9 PM ? Wednesday 2–9 PM ? Thursday 2–9 PM ? Friday 2–9 PM ? Saturday 2–9 PM

Quick Actions

Similar listings in category

Aubrey + Zach's Ice Cream serves creative scoops, loaded sundaes, and boozy slushies in Cincinnati. A fun neighborhood spot with a sweet twist on the classics.

Westwood

The Cone Zone serves classic soft-serve, hard scoop ice cream, and frozen treats to Cincinnati-area families looking for a sweet, no-fuss neighborhood stop.

Cincinnati

Dairy Corner is a Cincinnati-area soft-serve stop with a classic menu of cones, sundaes, and frozen treats that keep loyal locals coming back all summer.

Newtown