A List of Independent Cincinnati Ice Cream Shops
Discover Cincinnati’s sweetest hidden gems! This curated list highlights locally owned ice cream shops serving up unique flavors, handcrafted treats, and hometown charm. Taste the best of the Queen City—one scoop at a time.
The Colonel's Creamery
The Colonel’s Creamery is a national award-winning, small-batch artisan ice cream shop located in Florence, Kentucky.
The Colonel's Creamery in Florence, Kentucky, is a delightful ice cream
Award-Winning Quality: The "Colonel" (owner Don Lambert) is a recognized expert in the field, having won the prestigious "Iron Scoop" award for flavor innovation at the National Ice Cream Retailers Association convention.
Small-Batch Artistry: Unlike many standard soft-serve stands, this is a true artisan shop where ice cream is made in small batches on-site. Their "Winners' Circle Dutch Chocolate" and "Signature Vanilla" are both blue-ribbon prize winners.
Inventive Flavor Rotations: The menu is constantly evolving, featuring robust and sometimes exotic flavors alongside perfectly executed classics. They are known for high butterfat content, which gives the ice cream an exceptionally creamy texture.
The Atmosphere: The shop is designed with a sense of "Americana nostalgia," featuring the aroma of freshly baked waffle cones and music from radio’s golden era. It even includes a photo booth for families to capture memories.
Artisan Treats: Beyond standard scoops, they offer high-end sundaes, thick milkshakes, and pints to go, all served with a focus on "slow down and savor" quality.
⭐ Rating: 5.0/5 (53.0 reviews)
🕐 Hours: Sunday, 4-9 PM Monday, Closed Tuesday, Closed Wednesday, 4-9 PM Thursday, 4-9 PM Friday, 12-9 PM Saturday, 12-9 PM
Similar listings in category
Downtown Cincinnati's original spot for scratch-made, all-natural ice cream and unique desserts.
Scratch-made ice cream, natural ingredients, rotating flavors, and giant homemade marshmallows.